案例公告
法規釐清諮詢-申請總表
Statutory Regulation Clarification - Consulting Application Overview
| 統計至108年3月11日Until March 11, 2019 | 累計(106年8月迄今)Total (From August 2017 until now) |
| 完成釐清件數Clarification completed | 63件 |
法規釐清諮詢-議題總表
Statutory Regulation Clarification - Consulting Issues Overview Data Download
| 序號Serial No. | 法規釐清案件主旨Subject of Statutory Regulation Clarification Application | 主管機關Competent Authority | 公告時間Publish Time | 資訊揭露Information Disclosure |
| 1 | 4輪電動代步車得否比照2輪電動自行車上路 Can a four-wheeled electric scooter go on the road, as a two-wheeled electric bicycle is permitted to |
交通部路政司 Department of Railways and Highways, Ministry of Transportation and Communications |
106/11/10 |
 機關回函 Reply from the authority釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 2 | 車聯網設備蒐集用戶資料所產生之大數據是否屬個人資料範疇 Is the big data generated from the user information collected by IOV devices subject to the scope of personal information |
法務部法律事務司 Department of Legal Affairs, Ministry of Justice |
106/11/13 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 3 | 共乘平台媒合自用車與乘客並分攤行車成本費用，其駕駛是否涉及職業駕駛範疇 Carpool platforms match private cats and passengers, and share the driving cost among the riders. Does the carpooling driver meet the definition of professional driver |
交通部路政司 Department of Railways and Highways, Ministry of Transportation and Communications |
106/11/28 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 4 | 商品服務廣告行銷平台及其營運模式是否屬多層次傳銷 Is the goods and service advertising and marketing platform, and the operating model a multi-level marketing |
公平交易委員會公平競爭處 Department of Fair Competition, Fair Trade Commission |
106/12/26 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 5 | 3D列印輔具客製化教學與製造是否需具醫材製造商許可 Does the customized teaching and manufacture of 3D printed assistive device require any permit of medical device manufacturer |
衛生福利部食品藥物管理署 Food and Drug Administration of Ministry of Health and Welfare |
106/12/26 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 6 | APP平台刊登保險商品DM，不涉及商品解說、分析、比較、與販售等行為，是否仍須具備保險代理人或保險經紀人資格 Listing the DM of insurance product on an app does not involve any product introduction, analysis, comparison, and sales. Is the qualification of insurance agent or insurance broker required |
金融監督管理委員會保險局 Insurance bureau of Financial Supervisory Commission, Executive Yuan, R.O.C |
106/12/26 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 7 | 3D列印輔具製造是否需設置工廠 Does a 3D printed assistive device manufacturer need to set up a factory |
衛生福利部食品藥物管理署 Food and Drug Administration of Ministry of Health and Welfare |
107/01/15 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 8 | 電子煙之定性疑義 The questions about the nature of electronic cigarettes |
衛生福利部國民健康署 Health Promotion Administration, Ministry of Health and Welfare |
107/01/15 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 9 | 「生物質能源設施」是否屬農業設施中之綠能設施範疇 Is a “bioenergy facility” a green energy facility under the definitions of agricultural facility |
行政院農業委員會農糧署 Agriculture and Food Agency, Council of Agriculture, Executive Yuan |
107/01/15 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 10 | 中週波深層運動按摩機是否屬醫療器材之範疇 Whether mid-frequency deep tissue sport massager is within the definition of medical device |
衛生福利部食品藥物管理署 Food and Drug Administration of Ministry of Health and Welfare |
107/01/15 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 11 | 會員制住宿空間經營模式是否屬旅館業之範疇 Does the operating model of membership make the lodging space a hotel |
交通部觀光局 Tourism Bureau, Ministry of Transportation and Communications |
107/01/15 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 12 | 居家照護服務平台是否應申請設立就業服務機構之許可 Does a homecare service platform need to apply for the permit of employment service agency |
勞動部勞動力發展署 Worlforce Development Agency, Ministry Of Labor |
107/01/15 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 13 | 剩餘食物資訊之軟體設計者的食安責任 Responsibility of food safety on the designers of remaining food information software |
衛生福利部食品藥物管理署 Food and Drug Administration of Ministry of Health and Welfare |
107/01/15 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 14 | 「實境體感設備」與「電子遊戲機」之認定與區別 Determination and difference between the “VR devices” and the “arcade game machines” |
經濟部商業司 Department of Commerce, MOEA |
107/01/15 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 15 | 非自用遊艇得否做為營業用載客船舶 Can a non-price yacht be used as a passenger vessel for business operation |
交通部航港局 Maritime & Port Bureau, Ministry of Transportation and Communication |
107/01/29 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 16 | 二手車買賣所提供之試駕服務是否屬小客車租賃業範疇 Is the test drive service of preowned cars sales within the definition of passenger car rental and leasing |
交通部公路總局 Directorate General of Highways, Ministry of Transportation and Communications |
107/01/29 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 17 | 心理諮商師得否採線上方式執業之疑義 Questions about whether or not psychology consultants can practice online |
衛生福利部醫事司 Department of Medical Affairs, Ministry of Health and Welfare |
107/01/29 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 18 | 平台提供商家上架商品並建立會員制度，並依使用者類型配置營收分潤與獎金，是否屬多層次傳銷之範疇 If a platform allows the stores to list their products, establish a membership system, and allocate the profit sharing incentives and bonuses based on the types of user, is this a multilevel marketing |
公平交易委員會公平競爭處 Department of Fair Competition, Fair Trade Commission |
107/01/29 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 19 | 病人知情同意書是否有經主管機關公告排除電子簽章法適用之情形 Does the competent authority expressly exclude the application of the Electronic Signatures Act on the informed consent form for patients |
衛生福利部醫事司 Department of Medical Affairs, Ministry of Health and Welfare |
107/01/29 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 20 | 再生PU燃料之申請再利用許可及其實際審查程序進行方式之疑義 Questions about the application of re-use permit, and substantive re-new processes for renewable PU fuel |
經濟部工業局 Industrial Development Bureau, MOEA |
107/01/29 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 21 | 銀髮日托中心是否須受長期照顧服務法之規範 Are elderly day care centers subject to the regulations of the Long-term Care Service Act |
衛生福利部社會及家庭署 Social and Familiy Affair's Administration Ministry of Health and Welfare |
107/01/29 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 22 | 企業向外國跨境電商付費購買廣告勞務服務時，得否類推適用「跨境電子勞務交易課徵營業稅規範」 When the company purchases the advertisement of services from a foreign cross-border e-commerce, is the “Regulations of Income Tax on Cross-Border E-Commerce Transaction of Services” |
財政部賦稅署 Taxation Administration, Minstry of Finace, R.O.C |
107/01/29 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 23 | 共享車位與停車場業之區別事宜 Difference between shared parking and parking lot business |
交通部路政司 Department of Railways and Highways, Ministry of Transportation and Communications |
107/01/29 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 24 | 跨境電子支付平台與跨境支付結算系統提供換匯、支付、跨境轉帳、儲值等服務，是否屬法規管制業務 Are the cross-border e-payment platforms, and cross-border settlement systems which provide currency exchange, payment, cross-border transfer, value deposit, the business subject to regulatory control |
金融監督管理委員會銀行局 Banking Bureau, Financial Supervisory Commission |
107/01/29 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 25 | 以人工智慧程式(非傳統技術分析)提供股票、期貨之投資建議，是否有違反投顧投信法之疑慮 Questions about whether or not using AI programs (nonconventional technical analysis) to provide investment recommendations for stocks and futures violates the Securities Investment Trust and Consulting Act |
金融監督管理委員會證券期貨局 Securities and Futures Bureau, Financial Supervisory Commission |
107/01/29 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 26 | 茶葉製作成茶絲，進而欲加工製成茶菸，若茶絲未含尼古丁，茶絲或茶菸是否受菸害防制法管制 Tea leaves made into tea silk and further processed and manufactured into tea cigarettes; if tea silk does not contain nicotine, then whether or not the tea silk or tea cigarette shall be under the regulation of the “Tobacco Hazards Prevention Act” |
衛生福利部國民健康署 Health Promotion Administration, Ministry of Health and Welfare |
107/01/29 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 27 | 茶葉製作成茶絲，進而欲加工製成茶菸，若茶絲未含尼古丁，茶絲或茶菸是否受菸酒管理法管制 Tea leaves made into tea silk and further processed and manufactured into tea cigarettes; if tea silk does not contain nicotine, then whether or not the tea silk or tea cigarette shall be under the regulation of the “Tobacco and Alcohol Administration Act” |
財政部國庫署 National Treasury Administration, Ministry of Finance |
107/01/29 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 28 | 氣態二氧化氯之藥品安定性試驗，是否能以冷藏儲存等其他方式進行試驗 Can the stability test of chlorine dioxide gas be conducted in the manner of refrigerated storage or by other means |
行政院環境保護署毒物及化學物質局 Toxic and Chemical Substances Bureau, EPA, Executive Yuan |
107/01/29 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 29 | 以石油作虛擬儲存，是否須受石油管理法之規範 Is the virtual storage of gasoline subject to the regulations of the Petroleum Administration Act |
經濟部能源局 Bureau of Energy, Ministry of Economic Affairs |
107/02/14 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 30 | 計程車客運業得否同時兼營汽車貨運業 Can cab service engage in the operation of freight forwarder at the same time |
交通部路政司 Department of Railways and Highways, Ministry of Transportation and Communications |
107/02/14 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 31 | 瑜伽練習空間供練習者於夜間就地休憩或睡眠，是否有遭認定為旅館業之疑慮 Questions about whether or not the space for practicing yoga will be deemed as a hotel if it allows the practitioners to rest or sleep inside |
交通部觀光局 Tourism Bureau, Ministry of Transportation and Communications |
107/02/14 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 32 | 技藝家教課程媒合平台之家教教師所需報稅之所得類型、免稅範圍、費用標準等適用疑義 Questions about the type of income, exemption, fee rates required for the tutors of matching platform offering at-home skills tutoring courses to file tax return |
財政部臺北國稅局 National Taxation Bureau of Taipei, Minstry of Finace |
107/02/14 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 33 | 收取使用少量廢棄物進行處理設備之試驗是否須申請清除處理機構許可，或業者可否成為廢棄物清理法第74條之專責機關或相關機關 To receive a small amount of waste for testing the treatment equipment, is it required to apply for the removal and treatment facility permit, or the business will be deemed as a designated agency or relevant agency under article 74 of the Waste Disposal Act |
行政院環境保護署廢棄物管理處 Department of Waste Management, Environmental Protection Administration, Executive Yuan |
107/02/14 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 34 | 小客車租賃業者交由消費者單獨經由APP完成租車程序，是否有違應一併檢視車況之規定 When the car rental company allows the consumers to complete the rental process independently through the app, does it violate the requirement that it shall inspect the car conditions at the same time |
交通部公路總局 Directorate General of Highways, Ministry of Transportation and Communications |
107/03/01 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 35 | 智慧床墊所蒐集分析使用者之心跳呼吸等資訊是否屬個人資料保護法之個人資料 The information on heartbeat and respiration of users collected and analyzed by the smart mattress is considered to be personal information under the Personal Information Protection Act |
法務部法律事務司 Department of Legal Affairs, Ministry of Justice |
107/03/01 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 36 | 智慧床墊所蒐集分析使用者之心跳呼吸等資訊是否屬人體研究法之生理資訊 The information on heartbeat and respiration of users collected and analyzed by the smart mattress is considered to be physiological information under the Human Subjects Research Act |
衛生福利部醫事司 Department of Medical Affairs, Ministry of Health and Welfare |
107/03/01 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 37 | 租車媒合平台欲結合保險代理人提供「車損和責任險」保險產品，是否亦應具備保險代理人資格 The car rental matching platform plans to integrate the insurance product of “vehicle damage and liability insurance” provided by the insurance agency, whether or not it is necessary to be equipped with the qualification for an insurance agent. |
金融監督管理委員會保險局 Insurance bureau, Financial Supervisory Commission |
107/03/01 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 38 | 租車媒合平台之營運，是否應依小客車租賃業之規範成立營業機構 For the business operations of a car rental matching platform, whether or not a business institution shall be established according to the regulations for car-rental carriers. |
交通部路政司 Department of Railways and Highways, Ministry of Transportation and Communications |
107/03/01 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 39 | 活動媒合平臺舉辦「在地導覽」活動行程，是否涉及旅遊行程規劃及旅行業規定而須具備旅行業執照 When the event matching platform holds “local tours,” does it involve travel planning, and the requirements of the travel industry and have to obtain the travel agent license |
交通部觀光局 Tourism Bureau, Ministry of Transportation and Communications |
107/03/23 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 40 | 智慧型照護系統，應屬「身心障礙者輔具費用補助辦法」及「失能老人輔具購買及居家無障礙環境改善補助項目表」何一項目 How to classify smart care systems under the “Regulations on Subsidization for Medical Treatment and Auxiliary Appliances for the Disabled” and the “Schedule of Subsidization for Auxiliary Appliances for Incompetent Elderly and Accessible Living Environment Improvement” |
衛生福利部社會及家庭署 Social and Familiy Affair's Administration, Ministry of Health and Welfare |
107/03/23 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 41 | 以區塊鏈發行代幣方式進行私募資金是否有所限制 Is there any restriction on private placement by issuing tokens through a blockchain |
金融監督管理委員會證券期貨局 Securities and Futures Bureau, Financial Supervisory Commission |
107/03/23 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 42 | 非藥師宅配送藥到府服務是否違反藥師法執行業務之規定 Does having a non-pharmacist to perform home delivery of medicines violate the practice standards of the Pharmacists Act |
衛生福利部醫事司 Department of Medical Affairs, Ministry of Health and Welfare |
107/03/23 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 43 | 旅遊達人媒合服務平台業者之四種支付收費之營運模式，是否涉及旅行業業務而須具備旅行業執照 Does the operating model of providing four payment plans include travel business, which will require the travel blogger matching platform service provider to obtain the travel agent license |
交通部觀光局 Tourism Bureau, Ministry of Transportation and Communications |
107/03/23 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 44 | 個人資料保護法之特種個人資料，其蒐集、處理或利用須經當事人「書面」同意，是否得採電子簽章方式 For the specific personal information described in the Personal Information Protection Act, the collection, processing or use of such information requires the “written” consent of the information owner, whether or not the electronic signature method can be used |
經濟部商業司 Department of Commerce, MOEA |
107/04/16 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 45 | 病歷、醫療、健康檢查等敏感性個資之書面同意得否以電子文件為之 For the written consent on the sensitive personal information of the medical profile, medical treatment and health examination, whether or not an electronic document can be used for such written consent |
衛生福利部護理及健康照護司 Department of Nursing and Health Care, Ministry of Health and Welfare |
107/04/16 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 46 | 旅遊平台僅執行銷售、金流與行銷活動，不涉及帶團業務或代訂房，是否應取得旅行業執照 If a travel platform only processes the sales, cash flow and marketing activities and does not involve an in group tour guide or hotel booking agency service, does it have to obtain the travel agency license |
交通部觀光局 Tourism Bureau, Ministry of Transportation and Communications |
107/04/16 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 47 | 區塊鏈不動產證券化是否應適用不動產證券化條例 Does the Clauses of the Real Estate Securitization Act apply to the real estate securitization over the blockchain |
金融監督管理委員會證券期貨局 Securities and Futures Bureau, Financial Supervisory Commission |
107/04/20 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 48 | 攝影服務平臺提供攝影服務業務，並附隨設計安排交通食宿行程，該附隨服務是否屬於旅行業業務 If the photography service platform provides photography services and arrange the accompanying transportation, meal and accommodation, is the accompanying service a travel business |
交通部觀光局 Tourism Bureau, Ministry of Transportation and Communications |
107/04/20 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 49 | 整合各家行動支付軟體之app平台，是否亦須具備電子支付業者之資格 Does the app that coordinates the mobile payment software issued by different providers have to obtain the qualifications of an e-payment service provider |
金融監督管理委員會銀行局 Banking Bureau, Financial Supervisory Commission |
107/04/20 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 50 | 平台媒合急需周轉資金之中小企業及資金提供方，以支票、本票等作為融資標的之適法性問題 Questions about the legal issues when small and medium companies require urgent financing for platform matching, about the funding method and using check, or promissory note as financing target |
金融監督管理委員會銀行局 Financial Supervisory Commission |
107/06/06 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 51 | 燃油添加劑配方含有石化燃料，則該添加劑之製造、運輸、營業是否受到石油管理法所規範；此類產品認證機制與商品標註範圍之法律規範為何者 If the recipe of the fuel additives contains fossil fuel, are the manufacturing, transportation and business of that fuel additive subject to the Petroleum Administration Act; what law should apply in term of the certification mechanism and goods labeling and marking of this kind of product |
經濟部能源局 Bureau of Energy, Ministry of Economic Affairs |
107/06/08 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 52 | 透過音樂軟體將不同音樂著作結合創作之音樂著作權認定問題 Questions about determining the copyrights of the music composed by integrating different musical works with a music software |
經濟部智慧財產局 Intellectual Property Office, Ministry of Economic |
107/06/20 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 53 | 財團法人得否設立社創型閉鎖性公司 Can a foundation set up a closed company of social innovation |
衛生福利部社會及家庭署 Social and Familiy Affair's Administration, Ministry of Health and Welfare |
107/06/20 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 54 | 室內地圖創建系統蒐集記錄室內空間之特徵資訊是否違反著作權 Is collecting and recording the information of the features of an interior space with an indoor mapping system |
經濟部智慧財產局 Intellectual Property Office, Ministry of Economic |
107/07/30 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 55 | 將移動式小型氣化裂解廢棄物模組設備裝載於貨櫃車處理廢棄物或出售出租該設備，是否須取得廢棄物處理許可 Is waste disposal permit required for equipping hauler trucks with small-scale gas cracking based waste disposal module for sale or rent |
行政院環境保護署廢棄物管理處 Department of Waste Management, Environmental Protection Administration, Executive Yuan |
107/08/08 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 56 | 業者建立線上衛生教育系統，提供分級/科諮詢、報告閱讀及第二意見諮詢，是否涉及「醫療行為」範疇；以及提供海外人士衛教服務，是否不受國內醫療法規之規範 Regarding the entity's setting up online health and training system, providing grading/sectioning consultation, viewing reports and providing 2nd opinion consultation: is this kind of |
衛生福利部醫事司 Department of Medical Affairs, Ministry of Health and Welfare |
107/08/16 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 57 | 新型外牆建築材料是否符合現行建築相關法規認定標準 |
內政部營建署 Construction and Planning Agency Ministry of the Interior |
107/10/04 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority 釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 58 | 外國旅遊服務平台公司於我國設立處理平台金流代收代付及資料處理服務子公司之適法性 |
金融監督管理委員會綜合規劃處 Department of Planning, Financial Supervisory Commission |
107/11/14 |
釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 59 | 私立就業服務機構之法人可否委由電子支付機構收受儲值款項提供外籍勞工代收代付服務 |
金融監督管理委員會銀行局 Financial Supervisory Commission |
107/11/14 |
釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 60 | 點數儲值是否涉及電子支付條例業務範疇 |
金融監督管理委員會銀行局 Financial Supervisory Commission |
107/11/14 |
釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 61 | 投資分析軟體是否涉及證券投資信託及顧問法之資格 |
金融監督管理委員會證券期貨局 Securities and Futures Bureau, Financial Supervisory Commission |
107/11/14 |
釐清公告 Announcement of Clarification |
| 62 | 經營在地導覽服務平台 |
交通部觀光局 Tourism Bureau, Ministry of Transportation and Communications |
108/03/04 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority |
| 63 | 專家服務媒合網路平台所提供之律師法律諮詢服務，其數種運作及收費方式是否違反律師倫理規範相關規定 |
法務部 中華民國律師公會全國聯合會 Department of Legal Affairs |
108/03/07 |
機關回函 Reply from the authority |
執行單位：中華民國全國中小企業總會
地址：臺北市106羅斯福路二段95號6樓 電話：02-2366-0812 #265、269
Small and Medium Enterprise Administration, Ministry of Economic Affairs